Canada must remove all restrictions on foreign ownership in telecom sector: MPs

After several months of study, the House of Commons Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology released its final report on foreign investment in the telecommunications field. The conclusion to its report is featured here. The full document is available here. In reviewing Canada’s foreign ownership regime applicable to telecommunications common carriers, the Committee found that the regime is too restrictive when compared to that of other OECD member countries, and that the restrictions are having a negative impact on the Canadian telecommunications industry. Foreign ownership restrictions have played a role in impeding capital investment by new entrants in the Canadian telecommunications sector in the past decade. They have also been a factor in the recent financial instability of the industry, which saw a number of capital restructurings and bankruptcies. Moreover, since telecommunications is a critical element of the global, networked, knowledge-based economy, these restrictions are also likely stifling Canada’s productivity and economic growth performances. In summary, foreign ownership restrictions compromise, among other important economic contributions, the diffusion of new communications technologies and Canadians’ access to modern telecommunications services. For all these reasons, the Committee recommends the complete removal of Canada’s foreign ownership restrictions applicable to telecommunications common carriers. While this reform could conceivably lead to foreigners gaining control of a Canadian tele-communications carrier, the Committee is confident that the Investment Canada Act provides the government with the tools it needs to ensure that substantial foreign investment will be carried out in a way that is consistent with the public interest. The CRTC also has the authority and means to ensure that telecommunications services are provided at affordable prices to rural and remote regions of the country. The removal of these restrictions, however, is not a panacea for the telecommunications sector. The Committee is not convinced that removing the restrictions on FDI applicable to telecommunications common carriers will, for example, lead to increased access to broadband in rural and remote communities in the short term. The Committee further believes that tele-communications common carriers and broadcasting distribution undertakings can no longer be separated on the basis of their underlying distribution networks or the services they provide. The Committee believes that carriage and content are distinct entities, and that distribution can be separated from programming undertakings. Cultural policy objectives can be achieved by treating content and carriage separately. For these reasons, the Committee recommends the complete removal of the foreign ownership restrictions imposed on broadcasting distribution undertakings. The Committee views full liberalization of the ownership regime on a symmetrical basis to all carriers of signals competing in the same markets as being the best way of achieving government objectives as laid out in the Telecommunications Act and the Broadcasting Act. The Committee is also of the opinion that reforms to Canada’s foreign ownership regime must be the first step in a multi-step reform of the telecommunications and broadcasting sectors in Canada. From the Committee’s perspective, regulatory reform may be necessary to ease the transition from monopoly to a more competitive structure; and given technological and industrial convergence between telecommunications and broadcasting, reform of Canada’s political governance structure for these sectors may also be required. Because such reforms go beyond the Committee’s current mandate, the Committee recommends a broad review of these issues by a special parliamentary committee. Finally, the Committee is confident that these recommendations reflect the expert testimony it received; this testimony was thorough and comprehensive. The report’s recommendations imply that more work remains to be done in this important area, and the Committee is prepared to provide more parliamentary guidance in the near future. The Committee also looks forward to having the Minister appear before the Committee to explain how the federal government will act on the Committee’s recommendations.

Canada must remove all restrictions on foreign ownership in telecom sector: MPs

News | May 6, 2003

Unlock all the Canadian telecom, broadcasting and digital media news you need.

FREE TRIAL

SUBSCRIBE

Inside The Wire Report

Information

Hill Times Publishing

Get in Touch With Us